Back to section

Post a comment on the text below

Class: FailingRBSP (child of SurfaceWaterBody)

  1. Please include here any comments which apply to all the schema elements in this Class.
  2. In addition to those general schema element level comments, we welcome your views on: a) whether you think this Class can be simplified;  and b) whether you think the linkages with other reporting Classes or Schemas can be improved, and how;

Previous comments

  • ES - Spain (invited by kristpet (disabled)) 19 Mar 2019 13:11:42

    We propose to add new Quality check

    the guidance states:

    Conditional check: Report if, in Class 'QualityElement', qeStatusOrPotentialValue='3' when qeCode='QE3-3 - River Basin Specific Pollutants'.

    The previous check is insufficient because it only ensures consistency in one direction (from 'QualityElement' to 'FailingRBSP'), but it is also necessary to ensure it in the opposite direction (from 'FailingRBSP' to 'QualityElement'), that is:

    This field should be left empty if

    • in Class 'QualityElement', qeStatusOrPotentialValue<>'3'  or
    • in Class 'QualityElement', qeStatusOrPotentialValue='3'  AND qeCode<>'QE3-3 - River Basin Specific Pollutants'.


    • NO - Norway (invited by kristpet (disabled)) 03 May 2019 14:23:12

       

      We propose to add new Quality check

      the guidance states:

      Conditional check: Report if, in Class 'QualityElement', qeStatusOrPotentialValue='3' when qeCode='QE3-3 - River Basin Specific Pollutants'.

      The previous check is insufficient because it only ensures consistency in one direction (from 'QualityElement' to 'FailingRBSP'), but it is also necessary to ensure it in the opposite direction (from 'FailingRBSP' to 'QualityElement'), that is:

      This field should be left empty if

      • in Class 'QualityElement', qeStatusOrPotentialValue<>'3'  or
      • in Class 'QualityElement', qeStatusOrPotentialValue='3'  AND qeCode<>'QE3-3 - River Basin Specific Pollutants'.


       NO supports this

You cannot post comments to this consultation because you are not authenticated. Please log in.